Breathe Easy LP
 

 In-Plant Electrical / Mechanical

Thermal Imaging Applications 
1

Commonly inspected components1

  • (3 phase) Power distribution
  • Fuse boxes
  • Cables & connections
  • Relays/Switches
  • Insulators
  • Capacitors
  • Substations
  • Circuit breakers
  • Controllers
  • Transformers
  • Motors
  • Battery banks

Typical reasons for temperature hotspots or deviations

  • Unbalanced loads
  • Harmonics (3rd harmonic current in Neutral)
  • Overloaded systems/excessive current
  • Loose or corroded connections increased resistance in the circuit
    (typically one side of components heats up)
  • Insulation failure
  • Component failure
  • Wiring mistakes
  • Underspecified components (like fuses) would heat up on both side of the fuse

 
1Abnormal heating associated with high resistance or excessive current flow is the main cause of many problems in electrical systems. Infrared thermography allows us to see these invisible thermal signatures of impending damage before the damage occurs. When current flows through an electric circuit, part of the electrical energy is converted into heat energy. This is normal. But, if there is an abnormally high resistance in the circuit or abnormally high current flow, abnormally high heat is generated which is wasteful, potentially damaging and not normal.

1Ohm's law (P=I2R) describes the relationship between current, electrical resistance, and the power or heat energy generated. We use high electrical resistance for positive results like heat in a toaster or light in a light bulb. However sometimes unwanted heat is generated that result in costly damage. Under-sized conductors, loose connections or excessive current flow may cause abnormally high unwanted heating that result in dangerously hot electrical circuits. Components can literally become hot enough to melt.

1Infrared Solutions cameras enable us to see the heat signatures associated with high electrical resistance long before the circuit becomes hot enough to cause an outage or explosion. Be aware of two basic thermal patterns associated with electrical failure: 1) a high resistance caused by poor surface contact and 2) an over loaded circuit or multi-phase imbalance problem.

Contact Problems

1Heat is produced by current flow through a contact with high electrical resistance. This type of problem is typically associated with switch contacts and connectors. The actual point of heating may often be very small, less than a 1/16 inch when it begins. Below are several examples found with the IR SnapShot during customer demonstrations.

Thermogram A) is a motor controller for an elevator in a large hotel. One of the three phase connections was loose, causing increased resistance at the connector. The excess heating produced a temperature rise of 50 degrees C (90F). Thermogram B) is a 3-phase fuse installation where one end of one fuse has poor electrical contact with the circuit. The increased contact resistance caused a 45C (81F) hotter temperature at that connection than at the other fuse connections. Thermogram C) is a fuse clip where one contact is 55C (99F) hotter than the others. And thermogram D) is a two-phase wall plug-in where the wire connections were loose causing the terminals to heat 55C (100F) hotter than the ambient.


1

1

1

1

A) Controller

B) 3 Phase Fuse

C) Fuse Clip

D) Wall Plug


1All four of these examples were serious and needed immediate attention. Thermogram B) shows an interesting principal used in interpreting thermal patterns of electrical circuit. The fuse is hot at one end only. If the fuse were hot at both ends, the problem would be interpreted differently. An overloaded circuit, phase imbalance, or an undersized fuse would cause both ends of the fuse to overheat. Being hot at one end only suggests that the problem is high contact resistance at the heated end.

The wall plug in Thermogram D) was seriously damaged as seen in the visual picture below, however, it continued to operate until it was replaced.

1


Overloaded Circuit Problems

1The following thermograms show overloaded circuits. Thermogram E) shows a circuit panel in which the main breaker at the top is over heated 75C (135F) above ambient. This total panel is overloaded and in need of immediate attention. Thermograms E) and F) show all the standard circuit breakers over heated. Their temperatures were 60C (108F) above ambient. Although in the thermogram the wires are blue in color they are also hot, 45 to 50C (81 to 90F). This entire electrical system needs to be redone.

1

1

1

1

E) Circuit Panel

F) Circuit Panel

G) Controller

H) Current Xformer


1Thermogram G) shows one line of a controller that is about 20C (36F) above the others. This needs further investigation to determine why one wire is that much hotter than the others are and to determine the repair needed. Thermogram H) shows a current transformer that is 14C (25F) warmer than the other two transformers in a 3-phase service installation. This indicates a serious imbalance of the service or a faulty current transformer that could seriously impact the customer's utility bill.


Load Requirements

1When making an inspection it is important that the system is under load. Wait with the inspection for "worst case" or peak loads, or when the load is at least 40% (according to NFPA 70B). Heat generated by a loose connection rises as the square of the load; the higher the load, the easier it is to find problems.

Don't forget to consider the cooling effect of wind or other air movement.


Surface Temperatures Only

1Infrared cameras cannot see through electrical cabinets or solid metal bus trays. Whenever possible open enclosures so the camera can directly see the electrical circuits and components. If you find an abnormally high temperature on the outside surface of an enclosure, rest assured that the temperature is even higher, and usually much higher, inside the enclosure. Below are some thermograms taken of a bus enclosure, which identify a serious problem with the electrical buses inside the enclosure. The hot spots were on the order of 10C hotter than the ambient and 6C hotter than other parts of the bus enclosure.
I) J) K) L) Bus enclosures


Electric Distribution

1Literally hundreds of different pieces of equipment may be found in an electrical system. They start with the utility electricity production, high voltage distribution, switchyards and substations, and end with service transformers, switchgear, breakers, meters, local distribution, and appliance panels. Many utilities have purchased the FlexCam® or SnapShot® to help with their maintenance. And nearly every type of industry has bought Infrared Solutions cameras to help with maintenance on their end of the electrical distribution system.

1Thermogram M) is a service transformer that had leaked some cooling oil, resulting in dangerously over heated coils near the top. One connection was 160C (288F) above ambient. This transformer needed immediate replacement but the company wanted to delay the repair one month so it could be done during a scheduled total plant shutdown. They used the IR SnapShot camera to monitor the state of the transformer and successfully delayed the repair. Thermogram N) is for a pole mounted service transformer that has a connection 30C (54F) hotter than ambient. Such a condition required maintenance at the next convenient opportunity. Thermogram O) shows a hot main connection on an interrupter at a substation in Mexico. The connection was found to be 14C (25F) hotter than the others. This was believed to be a problem that needed attention. Thermogram P) shows an overhead connection in a Peru substation. It was less than 10C or (18F) above ambient and not of immediate concern.

1

1

1

1

M) Transformer

N) Transformer

O) Interrupter

P) Connection


Electrical Distribution

Thermal Imaging Applications
1

Commonly inspected components

  • (3 phase) Power distribution
  • Fuse boxes
  • Cables & connections
  • Relays/Switches
  • Insulators
  • Capacitors
  • Circuit breakers
  • Controllers
  • Transformers
  • Motors
  • Battery banks

Typical reasons for temperature hotspots or deviations

  • Unbalanced loads
  • Harmonics (3rd harmonic current in Neutral)
  • Overloaded systems/excessive current
  • Loose or corroded connections increased resistance in the circuit (typically one side of components heats up)
  • Insulation failure
  • Component failure
  • Wiring mistakes
  • Underspecified components (like fuses) would heat up on both side of the fuse

 
Infrared imaging and temperature analysis are a necessity to efficiently and accurately monitor substations, transmission lines, power connections, and other transmission equipment. With the revolutionary Infrared Solutions product line you will be able to diagnose potential problems before they become catastrophic, saving significant dollars on extensive repairs and downtime. By utilizing infrared technology, electric utility companies will be able to increase reliability, conserve costs, and save money. Below are some sample images of an infrared inspection conducted during a routine predictive maintenance check.

1

DLW1 D R2766 at Hwy Z & 21- Lower portion of elbow was 82.5 deg F, (50 deg above ambient) - circuit load was not checked. The warm part is where the elbow is over the bushing, a likely heat source is either the probe and socket or the OCR bushing. This did not appear to be a pin and connector heat source.

1


1

DLW substation- high side switch- latch appeared warm 52 deg F (ambient approx 30 deg)

1
1
1

 

1
1

WIN- Alliant GOAB- center contact on (East circuit) 1654 A.
Ambient ~21.2 deg, switch temp approx 54 deg F- not serious- should be checked again.

1

12/23/03, 7:25 AM at LWS- high side switches, step-down and substations okay.
12/23/03, 8:25 AM at WIN- see above photo and notes
12/23/03- QNC- High side switch and substation okay.
12/23/03- DLW- High side switch in substations warm- see above photo
Substation okay.
12/23/03- DLW 1 D, R 2766 at Hwy Z and 21- see photos

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

Mechanical Systems

Thermal Imaging Applications

Commonly inspected components

  • Motors
  • Pumps
  • Heat exchangers
  • Bearings
  • Gearboxes
  • Drive belts   

Typical reasons for temperature hotspots or deviations    

  • Bad cooling - due to reduced airflow
  • PQ problems like unbalance, overload or 5th harmonic (voltage) will cause heat dissipation
  • Bad alignment
  • Insulation problems with motor windings
  • Bearing problems - lubrication, wear, etc.
  • Friction due to wear, misalignment or inadequate lubrication     

Mechanical Systems

In all plants there are diverse collections of equipment that can be successfully inspected using infrared thermography. For most mechanical equipment the techniques used to inspect the equipment are straightforward, but specific knowledge and experience with some equipment is often required.

You should know the basic operation and heat flow characteristics of the machinery, understand heat related failure mechanisms, have safety inspection procedures and observe the machinery during startup and cool down as well as during normal operation. No one knows the equipment in a plant better than the plant personnel themselves do. It is very helpful to have past experience with the equipment and thermal images of the equipment during normal operations.

We have a few examples of thermography for mechanical systems. The first two thermograms, P) and Q) below show electric motors at 30C (54F) and 40C (72F) above ambient, respectively. Thermogram R) shows a motor coil under test. The camera operator is looking for shorts, which will show up as temperature anomalies. Thermogram S) is a coupling for a high horse power motor and is 6C (10F) below the motor bearing temperature and 12C (20F) below the machine bearing temperature. It is well within its normal operating temperature.

1

1

1

1

P) Electric motor

Q) Electric Motor

R) Coil Test

S) Coupler

Thermogram T) is an oil field natural gas compressor where the cylinder head in the lower left of the picture shows signs of a valve problem. Not counting the bolt head parts of the images, this cylinder head shows a 25C (45F) temperature gradient. This gradient was felt to be excessive and it resulted in a tear down and servicing of the compressor. Thermogram U) is an image of a rotating one-foot diameter 3 feet long pinion gear that drives a 50-foot diameter drum in a molybdenum mining operation. By monitoring the lengthwise temperature gradient, the technician could monitor the gear alignment and its life expectancy. Thermograms V) and W) are images of pipe with band heaters. V) shows the heaters on and functioning and W) shows them not working.

1

1

1

1

T) Compressor

U) Pinion Gear

V) Band Heater

W) Band Heater

Process Monitoring

Commonly inspected components    
Process Monitoring and Installations
  • Refractory insulation
  • Tanks and vessels
  • Steam systems/traps
  • Pipes and valves
  • Heaters/Furnaces
  • Manufacturing equipment
  • Plastics Industry (Molding)
  • Pulp & Paper (Rollers, handling equipment, etc)
  • Metal Foundry
  • Boilers and Reactors
  • Research & Development

Typical reasons for temperature hotspots or deviations    

  • Damaged structures caused by worn pipes etc
  • Abnormal heat flow/heat gradients
  • Gas or steam leakage   

Petrochemical - Paper Manufacturing - Plastic Injection Molding - Food Processing - Glass Manufacturing

Petrochemical

PetrochemicalThe petrochemical refining process is extremely energy intensive and requires careful thermalmonitoring to ascertain the safety and thermal efficiencies of each process. Examining such thermal processes with infrared equipment capable of doing high temperature measurement can provide a quick andaccurate diagnosis of problems and save refineries high damage-related costs. Refineries can attain a higher level of productivity and increase profitability by using infrared cameras to carry out tank level verification, condenser fin diagnosis, furnace maintenance, refractory loss management and electrical and mechanical maintenance.

Furnace Inspection – Infrared cameras facilitate the inspection of heater tubes in furnaces for carbon scale buildup. This phenomenon also known as "coking" can easily be detected with suitable high-temperature infrared equipment because areas with coke buildup show up as warmer than other areas of the tube surface.
This shows that the coke is precluding the product from uniformly absorbing the tube's heat. Additional disadvantages of coking include higher furnace firing rates and decreased tube life. This provides more incentive to maintenance personnel to perform regular infrared scans to protect against coking.

Condenser Tube Inspection - Occasionally the condenser tubes in a refinery can get plugged which can significantly deteriorate output and have an adverse effect on the efficient operation of the refinery. Infrared images of such tubes can reveal sections of the tube that are plugged, thereby, alerting maintenance personnel to the problem before it can result in more severe consequences.

High Temperature Pressure Pipelines – High temperature pressure pipelines are used extensively in petrochemical plants. Leakage and accidents due to it can occasionally take place after a certain period of time due to media corrosion, cracking due to welding defects or stress, and material deterioration. In order to ensure the safe operation of the pipes it is necessary to get an idea of the integrity of the pipe-walls and then replace only the critically damaged pipes. Since infrared thermography is non-contact, fast, harmless and easily deployable, it is a great tool for observing discontinuities in the heat-flow patterns resulting from wall defects for high temperature pressure pipes.

Thermocouple Validation – Infrared equipment can also provide a great non-contact mechanism for validating thermocouple temperature measurement. Thermocouples are installed at several points in a furnace in order to provide very accurate tube temperatures, but when coking occurs around the thermocouple, it is liable to either detach or provide inaccurate data. An infrared scan can prevent this by quickly validating the accuracy of a furnace tube temperature reading provided by a thermocouple. This assures a good product yield.

Paper Manufacturing

1Paper manufacturing is a competitive industry in which reducing operational costs and increasing profits is a constant challenge. The papermaking process which is based on water removal through drainage, mechanical pressing and the application of heat has several different stages that can provide a thermal imprint. Using infrared equipment to monitor each of these stages as well as preventing electrical and mechanical failure by carrying out traditional predictive maintenance with such equipment can result in a higher quality product and minimize costs by averting failures.

 

Drying Stage - Infrared imaging provides an excellent method for monitoring one of the most difficult parts of the paper manufacturing process, the drying stage. The cold streak towards the far end of the roll of paper is caused by evaporating cooling. This corresponds to variations in moisture resulting from uneven drying. Changes made in the drying process to correct this problem can be immediately monitored at all steps of production.

Moist Streaks on Paper - High-pressure showers are used to keep press section fabrics clean. Occasionally, the shower flow-pattern is transferred to the paper web and these patterns can be identified using infrared imaging. This condition can cause problems in the dryer section, such as rusting of return rolls which then leads to premature wear of the dryer fabric. In addition, paper containing wet streaks can have a detrimental effect on the quality and performance of the paper in a subsequent converting and printing process. Hence, infrared cameras can play a crucial role in identifying and eliminating the cause of such patterns before significant damage is sustained.

Steam Leaks - Steam leaks on steam coils for the dryer section pocket ventilation system can be identified during an infrared inspection of the paper machine. Such leaks can cause the paper machine to experience frequent paper breaks which can have an adverse effect on production. By virtue of a single infrared scan, not only is future inconvenience prevented, but the paper mill gains thousand of dollars in increased production.

Electrical – Paper mills, like other plants, can experience unexpected downtime due to electrical component failure such as electrical bus bars, line splices, switch disconnects, transformers, circuit breakers and distribution panels. These failures can easily be spotted ahead of time using infrared equipment and fixed before a breakdown stalls production.

Mechanical – Regular infrared inspection on mechanical systems such as motor windings, roll bearings and gearboxes can be carried out and maintenance work can be scheduled if aberrant 'hot spots' are observed.

Plastic Injection Molding

1Plastic manufacturing is a wonderful application for infrared cameras, both in monitoring the manufacturing process as well as traditional predictive maintenance. The nature of the manufacturing process is thermal. Obtaining a thermal image of a newly formed plastic part as it exits the mold can be used to diagnose quality problems and reduce scrap while increasing productivity and profitability. The plastics industry, hit hard by international competition, has an extreme focus on finding any conceivable way to increase profitability. Infrared cameras assist the manufacturing process to attain a higher level of productivity.


Cores and cavities – Monitoring the thermal profile of cores and cavities can predict problems with the process. An infrared image of a core can be used to determine if it is running too hot. A large temperature difference between cores in excess of 20deg F usually means the system is unstable.

Cooling lines – The wrong heat transfer in the wrong place at the wrong time can result in short shots, galling, splay, stuck parts, shear, material degradation and brittleness. Changing molds at times results in improper connection of cooling lines. Comparing thermal images of plastic parts as they exit the mold may be used to determine if the cooling lines are connected correctly and transferring the correct amount of heat.

Heater bands – The feed throat must not exceed a specific temperature or clogging will occur. The temperature of the heater bands near the feed throat can be easily monitored with an infrared camera.

Dryers – Drying systems, used to remove moisture from hoppers, must be monitored for correct temperatures. An infrared thermal analysis is a very quick method to ensure the drying process is functioning correctly.

Electrical – Thermal scans of electric motors and connections can prevent premature failure and costly down time.

 

Food Processing

1Food processing is a natural application for thermal imaging. Pre-cooked meats are an increasingly popular convenience for busy consumers. Cereals, pastries and snack foods all require precise baking protocols. In these food applications and many others, large volumes of food product must be cooked or baked with precision.


The Competing Boundaries of Safety, Quality and Economy
Process engineers constantly face the competing boundaries imposed by safety, product quality, and economy. Safety requires that the all parts of a food product be maintained above a threshold temperature for a specific time period to kill potentially dangerous bacteria. However, if the temperature is raised too high or the time period is excessive,the product becomes dry and overdone -- an unacceptable product quality. Production economy dictates that the line move rapidly to achieve targeted volumes and that the oven operate at a minimum temperature to reduce fuel expenses. The daily economies of production are tempered by the realization that a single safety violation may have disastrous economic and moral consequences for the entire corporation. Likewise, a brief lapse in product quality may undo years of accomplishment in a competitive marketplace.

Factors Impacting Product Temperatures
Thermal imaging provides the measurement capability to safely and economically achieve a product of high quality. Thermal imaging provides the ability to constantly monitor the temperatures of the product itself. Sophisticated oven and belt controls are valuable, but it is the product temperatures that are most critical. Product temperatures may vary significantly due to such parameters as:
1) oven temperature;
2) belt speed;
3) product volume;
4) product composition;
5) start-up conditions; and
6) product separation or placement.

A Distribution of Product Temperatures
As they exit an oven, products typically have a range or distribution of temperatures throughout their surface and volume. This distribution of temperatures is influenced by the numerous factors listed above. Those who measure the 'temperature' (singular) of a product with a single thermometer may be surprised to see the temperature variations evident in a thermal image. A thermal image is equivalent to an array of thousands of temperature probes placed over the surface of the product with the resulting data organized in the format of an image. A distribution of temperatures, instead of a single product temperature, is supported by common observations such as cookies with burnt edges and semi-liquid centers. Since safety, quality and economic concerns apply to all parts of the product, it is valuable to measure temperatures throughout the product.

Once the temperature distributions are measured, the process can be managed and optimized. If the distribution of temperatures is too wide, perhaps the belt speed may be reduced slightly to permit all parts of the product to achieve the desired temperature. Conversely, if the distribution is narrow, the belt speed may be increased while still maintaining product safety and quality.

Strengths of Thermal Imaging for Food Processing Applications
Thermal imaging technology, in its basic form, provides accurate measurements of surface temperatures. This is ideally suited for measuring products such as chips or bacon because of their thin profile. The calibrated images from a radiometric, infrared camera work well without further processing.

For products with substantial thickness, the surface temperatures may be used as an input into a mathematical model describing the thermal properties of the product. With such a model, volumetric thermal properties and statistical analyses may be extended to many additional products. With sufficient post-processing power, these measurements may be made in real-time.

Glass Manufacturing

1Monitoring temperatures at critical junctures during production is imperative for the full understanding and efficient control of the glass manufacturing process. Since the nature of the glass manufacturing process is thermal, the quality of the glass manufactured is dependent on obtaining accurate temperature readings of various elements such as the glass mold, "gob", steel conveyor belt and the furnace. Using easily deployable infrared equipment to monitor these temperatures as well as preventing electrical and mechanical failure by carrying out traditional predictive maintenance with such equipment can result in a higher quality product and minimize costs by averting failures.

Gob Temperature – Glass is transported from the furnace to the mold in a runner. At the end of the runner, a plunger forces out the glass in balls called "gobs" into chutes that lead up to the mold machine. It is extremely important to monitor the temperature of the "gobs" because it controls the weight of the glass, its viscosity and the formation of the container in the mold. Therefore, the quality of the final product can be ensured by carrying out convenient non-contact infrared inspection of the gobs as they leave the plunger.

Belt Temperature – Glass containers are transported on a steel conveyor belt from the mold machine to the annealing lehr. In order to prevent the belt from cooling the bottoms of the containers unevenly, thereby causing breakage, the belt is heated with gas flames before reaching the bottling machines. It is critical for manufacturers to measure the belt temperature at regular intervals in order to prevent breakage and guarantee a high enough return to maintain profitability in a competitive industry. An infrared camera is ideal for such an application.

Glass Mold – It is necessary for manufacturers of glass containers to monitor the temperature of the glass mold closely because it affects the quality of the containers. If the mold is not cooling properly, the container will not retain its shape after exiting the mold or if the mold is too cool, the container will not be molded properly. Hence, it is to the benefit of container manufacturers to use infrared equipment to acquire mold temperatures from time to time in order to ascertain that the cooling is proceeding at an appropriate temperature.

Furnace Monitoring – Economical melting of raw materials into glass requires constant supervision and monitoring. Depending on their size, glass furnaces are capable of producing anywhere from 50 to 600 tons of glass per day. Most furnaces are fired by natural gas through the side ports and the melting temperature is around 1200°C. Molten glass eventually flows out of the furnace through the feeders to the forming machines attached to each furnace. The condition and safety of the refractory structure of the whole furnace and refiner is extremely important. A high-temp infrared camera can very easily be used to do check-ups to minimize the possibility of glass break-out or refractory failure.